Past Patriot Baseball Champions
| Year | Champion | Head Coach | Record (Patriot League) | Tournament MVP | Tournament Runner-Up |
| 1991 | Fordham | Dan Gallagher | 35-16-0 (12-3) | no tournament | no tournament |
| 1992 | Fordham | Dan Gallagher | 29-15-0 (12-3) | no tournament | no tournament |
| 1993 | Fordham | Dan Gallagher | 32-27-0 (13-7) | Joe Schultz, Fordham | Navy |
| 1994 | Navy | Bob MacDonald | 24-18-1 (11-9) | Steve Mauro, Navy | Army |
| 1995 | Navy | Bob MacDonald | 33-20-0 (19-5) | no tournament | no tournament |
| 1996 | Bucknell | Gene Depew | 24-23-0 (14-6) | Pete Cann, Bucknell | Navy |
| 1997 | Army | Dan Roberts | 26-20-1 (15-5) | Bryan Price, Army | Bucknell |
| 1998 | Navy | Bob MacDonald | 25-15-0 (15-5) | Luke Braham, Navy | Bucknell |
| 1999 | Navy | Bob MacDonald | 27-22-1 (15-5) | Pat Klokow, Navy | Bucknell |
| 2000 | Army | Joe Sottolano | 24-20-1 (10-8) | Josh Minney, Army | Navy |
| 2001 | Bucknell | Gene Depew | 31-19-0 (14-6) | Brad Gething, Bucknell | Navy |
| 2002 | Navy | Steve Whitmyer | 23-25-0 (13-7) | Matt Foster, Navy | Lehigh |
| 2003 | Bucknell | Gene Depew | 26-17-0 (15-5) | Brian Day, Bucknell | Navy |
| 2004 | Army | Joe Sottolano | 37-15-0 (17-3) | Justin Long, Army | Lafayette |
| 2005 | Army | Joe Sottolano | 39-14-0 (17-3) | Walker Gorham, Army | Lehigh |
| 2006 | Lehigh | Sean Leary | 28-28-0 (13-7) | Kyle Collina, Lehigh
Joe Matteo, Lehigh | Bucknell |
| 2007 | Lafayette | Joe Kinney | 33-20-0 (17-3) | Mike Raible, Lafayette | Army |
| 2008 | Bucknell | Gene Depew | 30-24-2 (10-10) | Jason Buursma, Bucknell | Navy |
| 2009 | Army | Joe Sottolano | 36-21 (13-7) | Ben Koenigsfeld, Army | Lafayette |
| 2010 | Bucknell | Gene Depew | 25-35 (8-12) | Doug Schribman, Bucknell | Holy Cross |
| 2011 | Navy | Paul Kostopoulos | 33-23-1 (12-8) | Ben Nelson, Navy | Army |
| 2012 | Army | Joe Sottolano | 41-15 (18-2) | Zach Price, Army | Holy Cross |
| 2013 | Army | Joe Sottolano | 29-23 (11-9) | Chris Rowley, Army | Holy Cross |
| 2014 | Bucknell | Scott Heather | 31-21-1 (15-5) | Joe Ogren, Bucknell | Lehigh |
| 2015 | Lehigh | Sean Leary | 25-31 (12-8) | Mike Garzillo, Lehigh | Navy |