| Year |
Champion |
Head Coach |
Record (Patriot League) |
Tournament MVP |
Tournament Runner-Up |
| 1990 |
Fordham |
Frank Schnur |
12-7-1 (4-2-0) |
Chris Donovan, Fordham |
Lafayette |
| 1991 |
Army |
Joe Chiavaro |
10-4-3 (4-2-1) |
Phillip Shearer, Army |
Lehigh |
| 1992 |
Colgate |
Mike Doherty |
13-4-3 (5-1-1) |
Brian Wycall, Colgate |
Army |
| 1993 |
Army |
Joe Chiavaro |
13-5-1 (5-2-0) |
Tony Dedmond, Army |
Colgate |
| 1994 |
Lafayette |
Jeff Gettler |
13-3-3 (5-0-2) |
Geddes Alexander, Lafayette |
Army |
| 1995 |
Lafayette |
Nelson Rodriguez |
12-7-2 (4-1-1) |
Eric Rosenbloom, Lafayette |
Navy |
| 1996 |
Army |
Joe Chiavaro |
11-9-0 (5-1-0) |
A.J. Florkowski, Army |
Navy |
| 1997 |
Colgate |
Mike Doherty |
10-7-4 (5-0-1) |
Jeff Lipman, Colgate |
Lehigh |
| 1998 |
Lafayette |
Tim Lenahan |
16-4-0 (5-1-0) |
Leidy Klotz, Lafayette |
Lehigh |
| 1999 |
Lafayette |
Tim Lenahan |
8-8-3 (2-3-1) |
Craig Schroeder, Lafayette |
Navy |
| 2000 |
Lehigh |
Dean Koski |
12-5-3 (3-2-1) |
Dan Perciballi, Lehigh |
Lafayette |
| 2001 |
American |
Todd West |
13-8-2 (6-1-0) |
Bobby Brennan, American |
Holy Cross |
| 2002 |
Holy Cross |
Elvis Comrie |
13-5-1 (5-2-0) |
Rusty Guidici, Holy Cross |
Lehigh |
| 2003 |
Lafayette |
Dennis Bohn |
11-6-3 (4-1-2) |
Ralph Rapuano, Lafayette |
Lehigh |
| 2004 |
American |
Todd West |
15-6-2 (6-1-0) |
Garth Juckem, American |
Lehigh |
| 2005 |
Lafayette |
Dennis Bohn |
13-5-2 (5-2-0) |
Mike Tortora, Lafayette |
American |
| 2006 |
Bucknell |
Brendan Nash |
9-8-6 (3-3-1) |
Joey Kuterbach, Bucknell |
Lafayette |
| 2007 |
Colgate |
Erik Ronning |
9-6-5 (4-1-2) |
Dan Belke, Colgate |
Lafayette |
| 2008 |
Colgate |
Erik Ronning |
12-6-3 (5-1-1) |
Alex Weekes, Colgate |
Holy Cross |
| 2009 |
Bucknell |
Brendan Nash |
17-6-0 (5-2-0) |
Patrick Selwood, Bucknell |
American |
| 2010 |
Bucknell |
Brendan Nash |
10-9-2 (3-2-2) |
Ross Liberati, Bucknell |
American |
| 2011 |
Colgate |
Erik Ronning |
11-5-6 (4-1-2) |
Steven Miller, Colgate |
American |
| 2012 |
Lafayette |
Dennis Bohn |
9-8-4 (3-1-3) |
Nathan McDonald, Lafayette |
American |
| 2013 |
Navy |
Dave Brandt |
16-4-2 (9-0-0) |
Guy Skord, Navy |
Holy Cross |
| 2014 |
Bucknell |
Brendan Nash |
10-10-3 (4-3-2) |
Sebastian Blickman, Bucknell |
Boston University |
| 2015 |
Lehigh |
Dean Koski |
13-6-3 (4-3-2) |
Jamie Luchini, Lehigh |
American |
| 2016 |
Colgate |
Erik Ronning |
13-7-2 (5-3-1) |
Ethan Kutler, Colgate |
American |