| Year | Champion | Head Coach | Site | Joe Abrahamson Award
(Tournament MVP) |
| 1990 | Army | Bob Detrich | Davis Fieldhouse Courts (Bucknell) | award established in 1993 |
| 1991 | Bucknell | Craig Reynolds | Memorial Tennis Courts (Colgate) | award established in 1993 |
| 1992 | Army | Both Detrich | Davis Fieldhouse Courts (Bucknell) | award established in 1993 |
| 1993 | Army | Dr. Steve Strome | Goodman Campus Courts (Lehigh) | Marco Coen, Army |
| 1994 | Army | Dr. Steve Strome | Joe Abrahamson Memorial Courts (Colgate) | Marty Whelan, Army |
| 1995 | Army | Dr. Steve Strome | Lehigh Tennis Center (Lehigh) | Marco Coen, Army |
| 1996 | Navy | John Officer | Davis Fieldhouse Courts (Bucknell) | Silas Bouyer, Navy |
| 1997 | Navy | John Officer | Joe Abrahamson Memorial Courts (Colgate) | Mitch Koch, Navy |
| 1998 | Navy | Paul D'Amico | Goodman Campus Courts (Lehigh) | Silas Bouyer, Navy |
| 1999 | Navy | John Officer | Tennis Center (Navy) | Mitch Koch, Navy |
| 2000 | Army | Dr. Steve Strome | Clinton Courts (Army) | Arnie Albornoz, Army |
| 2001 | Army | Dr. Steve Strome | Eastside Raquet Club (Manilus, N.Y.) | Marshall Clay, Army and Andrew Burdette, Army |
| 2002 | American | Martin Blackman | Reeves Courts (American) | Tushar Garg, American |
| 2003 | American | Martin Blackman | Reeves Courts (American) | Juan Jaysingh, American |
| 2004 | American | Martin Blackman | Reeves Courts (American) | Guillaume Tarralle, American |
| 2005 | Army | Jim Poling | Montclair Country Club/Reeves Courts (American) | John Houghton, Army |
| 2006 | Army | Jim Poling | Malek Tennis Courts (Army) | Michael Good, Army and Eddie Kang, Army |
| 2007 | Navy | John Officer | USNA Courts (Navy) | Nate Nelms, Navy |
| 2008 | Navy | John Officer | Joe Abrahamson Memorial Courts (Colgate) | Alex James, Navy |
| 2009 | Navy | John Officer | Malek Tennis Courts (Army) | Nate Nelms, Navy |
| 2010 | Navy | John Officer | Varsity Tennis Courts (Bucknell)
West Branch Tennis Courts, S. Williamsport, Pa. | Owen Bullard, Navy |
| 2011 | Army | Jim Poling | Ulrich Varsity Courts (Lehigh)
Lewis Tennis Center | Asika Isoh, Army and Gary Kushnirovich, Army |
| 2012 | Navy | John Officer | USNA Courts (Navy) | Calvin Mark, Navy |
| 2013 | Lehigh | Wouter Hendrix | Joe Abrahamson Memorial Courts (Colgate) | Matt Savran, Lehigh |
| 2014 | Army | Jim Poling | Malek Tennis Courts (Army) | Alex Van Velzer, Army |
| 2015 | Navy | Chris Garner | Varsity Tennis Courts (Bucknell) | Austin Jones, Navy |